Username Password
join FREE
everything rugby
ArchiveArchive
2009 (5)
November (3)
Hi
Purple Drain Purple Drain
Northampton's Clarke can fill England shoes
December (2)
Ireland robbed - again
Gouging - rugby's shame
2010 (19)
January (4)
ENGLAND UNDER 20 SQUAD ANNOUNCED FOR SIX NATIONS
ENGLAND EPS and SAXONS SQUADS ANNOUNCED
WHO WILL CAPTAIN ENGLAND?
SEVENS HEAVEN
February (3)
MISSING BILL AND FINDING PROPS
SUPER 14 PREVIEW - ROUND ONE
England unchanged starting XV for Ireland at Twickenham
April (3)
THE BEST RUGBY WEEKEND OF THE YEAR?
Jimmy Gopperth - Newcastle's saviour
ADVANCE AUSTRALIA - TO WORLD CUP GLORY?
May (1)
ENGLAND TOUR PARTY ANNOUNCED
June (1)
England Under 20s v Australia - RFU press release
July (1)
England Squads announced
August (2)
AVIVA PREMIERSHIP - ROUND ONE PREVIEW
England Women's team for World Cup semi-final v Australia
September (1)
England Rugby Sevens squad for Commonwealth Games
October (2)
Delhi Diary - by England Sevens captain Ben Gollings
Prop Idol - Andrew Sheridan
November (1)
All Blacks triumph at Twickenham - Rupert Bates
2011 (37)
January (4)
Wallabies legend George Smith and Toulon help Queensland flood victims
WILL THE REBELS YELL? by Rupert Bates in Melbourne
England Saxons to play Italy A
MARC LIEVREMONT - profiled by Rupert Bates
February (6)
THE RUGBY WEEKEND REVIEWED - by Rupert Bates
England unchanged for Italy at Twickenham
ENGLAND DEBUT FOR CORBISIERO
England U20 thrash Italy in Bath
GARETH DELVE - THE FIRST WELSHMAN IN SUPER RUGBY
FEELING SORRY (just a little) for CIPRIANI
March (3)
Old Deer Park fund-raiser for Queensland and Christchurch
BIG WIN FOR ENGLAND U20
SCHOOLS RUGBY FINALS
April (1)
AVIVA PREMIERSHIP RUGBY AWARDS - NOMINATIONS
May (3)
HEINEKEN CUP FINAL
England XV to play Barbarians
AVIVA PREMIERSHIP FINAL - TEAMS
June (6)
England Saxons win Churchill Cup
England into Junior World Championship semi-finals
England World Cup training squad announced
England U20 team for World Junior Championship semi-final
England through to World Junior Championship final
NEW ZEALAND WIN JUNIOR WORLD CHAMPIONSHIP
July (2)
IRB Junior Player of the Year short-list
He has climbed highest mountains...
September (5)
JONNY WILKINSON TALKS EXCLUSIVELY TO EVERYTHING RUGBY
THE DAY GEORGIA NEARLY CAUSED RUGBY'S GREATEST-EVER UPSET
HELL FREEZES OVER
THE LONG AND SHORT OF IT
GHOSTS OF BATTLES PAST
October (7)
WE FEEL YOUR PAIN
FALLING LEGENDS
GRASS ROOTS BUT CLEAN KIT
RED, RED WHINE
SPANGHERO - THE BOYS FROM BRAM
THIERRY DUSAUTOIR - IRB PLAYER OF THE YEAR
NEW ZEALAND WINS WORLD CUP
LabelsLabels
LinksLinks
Our Sponsor
Our Sponsor
Your NewsRED, RED WHINE

Friday 21st October 2011
RED, RED WHINE

 During the World Cup Rupert Bates wrote a weekly column from the UK for Rugby News New Zealand magazine (www.rugby.co.nz). This article was first published in Rugby News October 20th.


For the French red wine; for the Welsh red whine. And we thought you lot were one-eyed. The coverage over here reminded me, with some notable exceptions, that former players however glorious their pasts, should just play golf and leave rational analysis to others.

The red card given to Wales captain Sam Warburton by referee Alain Rolland came after just 18 minutes. Now I was not expecting any sober reflection from Welshmen as most of them had been on the beer since sunrise in preparation for the most momentous morning in the history of this great rugby nation.

But in the ITV studios beaming pictures to us in the UK sat three forwards from the pantheon of back-row play in Francois Pienaar, Lawrence Dallaglio and Martyn Williams. They had 22 minutes and an ad break to think about the incident objectively and watch the replay a few times.

I exempt Williams from criticism. The man who Warburton succeeded on the open-side flank for Wales has played 99 times for his country and was entitled to be emotional. But Pienaar and Dallaglio, not helped by ITV anchorman Steve Rider calling the decision “unbelievable,” proceeded to spout passionate, biased nonsense and even 24 hours later after the New Zealand-Australia semi-final the former Springboks captain was still at it.

We all agree there was no intent by Warburton to inflict harm on France wing Vincent Clerc. If there is malicious intent to tip tackle someone and drive their head into the ground, it should not just be a red, it should be a life ban and a GBH charge. Don’t worry I won’t mention Tana Umaga and keven Mealamu on Brian O’Driscoll. Whoops I just did.

The defence of Warburton was that he’s a lovely guy and a star of the tournament and by removing the Wales seven after 18 minutes Rolland had ruined the game. I think a broken neck for Clerc might have ruined the game too.

The television pundits seemed to think that, despite the tackle happening right under Rolland’s nose, the referee should have consulted his assistants and then, not that he was entitled to, gone to the TMO for the adjudication on the colour of the card.

Rolland was also expected to look at the time on the clock and the weight of the occasion and think: ‘Hang on we’re only 18 minutes into a World Cup semi-final and the biggest game in Welsh history, I better bottle it and just make it yellow.”

The law rather naively dictates that Warburton, in the heat of battle and on a surge of momentum, should, rather than just letting go, have gently laid Clerc on the grass, kissed his forehead and sung the Frenchman a lullaby.

It may be an interpretive law, but because rugby is a physical game with serious injury risks is precisely why player safety is paramount, so rugby-mad dads singing lullabies to new-born sons in their cots feel comfortable about them playing this greatest of games.

 

Posted by: , on October 21st 2011 on 08:03pm
Leave a Comment

Name:
Email:
Website:

Comment:
Sponsors
join Free
Free Site
Online Coaching
Directory